The Tigers (12-3) gained revenge for a loss to the Colts in the first round. Douglas took a 1-0 lead when Andrew Andraski threw the ball in from about 30 yards and Ross Gardner took it and beat two defenders to score.
After Wooster scored to tie the game, Timo Loullgen sent a ball into the goal box and as Christian Salazar was about to shoot, he was taken down. Edgar Arceo converted the penalty kick to give Douglas a 2-1 halftime lead.
Arceo was also taken down in the goal box in the second half, but Douglas failed to convert the penalty kick. Eddie Vega, though, sent a free kick to Jose Alcaraz, who scored on a header with five minutes left to put the game away.
Goalie Ivan Gonzalez made three saves and Kyle Gardner and Geoff Rahe also played well for Douglas. The Tigers did lose Jeff Crozier to a knee injury. The extent of his injury is unknown.